Cookies with Personality

Sugar cookies are my game. I'm a self-taught baker and cookie artist. What started as a hobby became my extra special side hustle. I work part-time outside of the home so making cookies brings me joy.

Pricing

Pricing starts at $40 per dozen and depends on size, design style and selection. I'm happy to recreate cookies that you've seen online or in Pinterest BUT know that I'll be making my version and not an exact copy, out of respect to other cookie artists.

Need some Custom Cookies?

Let customers speak for us

from 32 reviews
Cute and Delicious

These where so cute almost did not want to eat however knowing how good they are we had to. What a great treat

Terri Frakes
SURPRISE! It’s a Cookie Box!
SURPRISE! It’s a Cookie Box!
Amazing

These cookies were awesome. Not only did they look adorable, they were delicious. 😋

Rikki
Turkey Day Placeholders
Turkey Day Placeholders
Never disappoints.

These were the cutest cookies and tasted so yummy!
I've never been disappointed by the cookies I order from here. They are always creative, made with quality ingredients. Highly recommend.

Deena Schiek
Hello Hallomeow
Hello Hallomeow
Love the kitties

Deliciously adorable đŸ„°

Susan J
Hello Hallomeow
Hello Hallomeow
Good cookies

Always good cookies. Looking forward yo receiving this order. Thanks Kristi.

C.H.
Custom for Carol #2
Custom for Carol #2
Amazing

I only have one complaint!!!!! They never last more than 2 days!!! Love love love them... I get the Vegan recipe, so yummy! The butterflies are always decorated so beautiful. Definitely one of my favorite designs.

Susan J
The Butterflies!
The Butterflies!
Amazing

Got these with the vegan recipe and am hooked!!! Ordered 2 more dozen immediately. Love love love them!!

Susan J
Mom’s Flowers (Basket set)
Mom’s Flowers (Basket set)
So good

These were so good they were gone in 10 minutes 😜

Susan J
Love Crackers. Kristi’s Version
Love Crackers. Kristi’s Version

Always a happy with bite the head off cookies!

Lesa Joyce
Birthday Coffee!
Birthday Coffee!

As always, Kristi designs and bakes delicious cookies. Friends and Hanukkah this year were a hit with all of our guests!

Karen Mahoney
Custom for Karen
Custom for Karen
Worth every bite

These are the only “store bought” cookies my daughter will eat. Always fresh always cute always yummy.

Adrienne Van Houten
Dozen of Christmas Variety
Dozen of Christmas Variety
Best Cookie Lady Ever!

Can't wait to use the cards!

Jenny Jara
Cookie Card
Cookie Card
Halloween cuties

My order that included pumpkins, ghosts, jars of poison, haunted house & skeletons were well received. They were adorable! Almost made them too cute to eat... ALMOST! They were so very delicious 😋

Susan J
Custom for Susan ( Halloween)
Custom for Susan ( Halloween)
Wedding cookies

Not only were these custom cookies delicious but they were beautiful and received rave reviews by the guests. I have never been let down by BTHOC and will continue to order from Kristi!

Susan J
Custom for Susan #2
Custom for Susan #2
Awesome Cookies

Very Cute and Taste Santa (AKA - myself) Love cookies

Terri Frakes
Christmas Minis Variety
Christmas Minis Variety